I Blog, Therefore I Am

…with all due apologies to Descartes, and every other blogger who thought they said it first.  But of course, I really said it first.  I think.  And I offer the following as testimony:

This was the card I used back at BlogHer way back when that site was just a lively bunch of women bloggers.  Before it became an industry.  That was, oh, about 2006 or 7.

The idea was that ByJane the blog, which was, after all, my by-line (byJane, get it?) was my personal version of Life magazine: a bit of this and a bit of that, all linked together merely by the fact that it all came from my head.  My credo, if you can’t read the small print, was this: This was my attempt to avoid the conflict that Lucie brought up in her response to my post the other day:

 Working with internet gurus [she wrote], it was drilled into me to pick a niche and strive to work in that context, yet I am finding I prefer to write about whats going on in my life. aka what’s bugging me at the moment. 

The internet gurus do say you must have a niche.  Better to have twenty blogs each devoted to a different topic than one blog that covers twenty topics, they insist.  The idea is that you build a community of loyal readers who know they can come to your blog for that certain special something that they’re interested in.  Don’t swerve from your niche because you’ll piss people off; just imagine their response if they come expecting food blogging and find you’re giving them political rants.

I’ve just never been able to follow the rules (in this or anything else in life!).  The result is that I’m not as successful as a blogger as if I’d been obedient.  But I am successful, in my own way and by my own reckoning.

The fact is that despite all the talk of metrics and stats, success in blogging is really totally subjective. Success is a function of whether or not you’ve met your goals, and there are a number of viable goals that bloggers have.  Here’s just some:  for self-expression, to communicate, to share knowledge, to teach a craft or skill, to sell a service, to sell merchandise, to hone your craft as a writer, to vent, to figure out what you think–should I go on?

You really need to know why you’re blogging–what your Purpose is–in order to even judge your success.  According to Technorati’s State of the Blogosphere Report this year, 60% of the respondants say they blog as hobbyists.  Of those, 72% judge their success by the mere fact that they’ve been able to speak their minds.  Those are some pretty impressive numbers, don’t you think.

My reasons for blogging have everything to do with writing and teaching and self-expression.  What are yours?

 

  • K M Thwaite

    I agree.. if you don’t enjoy it then it’s ointless

  • Pjpusser3

    I don’t blog but then I need a course with the illustrious Jane Gassner to learn how to. Then I’ll figure out my goals.

    • Jane

      Tuition to you is always gratis…! Ya know, I bet we can get an advance for blogging our way through Italy. Sort of an older woman’s version of Eat Pray Love.

  • http://www.emptyhousefullmind.com/ Sharongreenthal

    I started blogging for my own satisfaction. My readers expect to hear my voice, whatever the topic. My “niche” is my brain! I suppose if I was in this to make big bucks I’d care more about what the gurus say, but until then, I’ll just keep blogging in my own merry way.

  • DuchessOmnium

    I am with you on this one. In fact I was sorry when you dropped ByJane, because I always liked your original idea that ByJane was whatever interested you and Midlifebloggers was an online magazine. But I know we have been through that before.

    As for me, I rate success if I actually write a post, but that’s my own place right now. I hope to aspire to better!

    Btw, your site no longer allows me to click on commenters and get to their blog. I miss that. Can you bring it back?

    • Jane

      Duchess,
      I’ll check on the comment thingie.

      And how are you doing in aspirations to write more?

  • http://barbarashallue.typepad.com/ Barbara

    I blog about whatever pops in my mind – “My Life” is my niche. I started a blog for my photography, but each of them is just a place to pop what interests me (one for words, one for photos), not to be first in a niche. All of the social media stuff gets on my nerves sometimes.

  • KingMidget

    I can’t imagine anything more boring than finding a niche and sticking to it, whether it is in the type of fiction I write or the topics on which I blog. My reasons for blogging … because I want to. I do hope that my blog will eventually grow into a place where people will come for conversation on a range of topics. But, I know that will take time to develop.

  • Melinda Folse

    I blog because I wrote a book that keeps on adding new chapters. As I continue to play around with the broad-based ideas and concepts that went into the writing of this book — and as its community builds and I hear more and more stories about women finding their midlife power with the help of horses — I just can’t stop. I guess it’s a niche, but a big one. So that’s a good thing because I have plenty of room to romp with my author-ly meanderings.e? Still, I have to wonder, how do we really measure blog success on the Internet? I have to believe if we have something to say that might do someone some good or point them to an idea or resource they might not have thought about, it’s a good thing. And besides that, if we keep all this stuff bottled up inside us we might blow up.

  • Mary Lou Floyd

    Hi Jane, As a supporter of our blog you know we are focusing on women who are now looking to take charge of their lives and set their own rules in all areas. That’s a broad niche and we find ourselves writing on a dozen different topics that we think have relevance to this next life. We just recently put up a manifesto and tried to use it to set more limited categories and as a way to differentiate us further. It didn’t really work. So we kept the manifesto and stuck with our same topics. We’ll differentiate by making sure we speak directly to our niche under each of those categories. This way we always have something to write about. Thanks Jane.
    Maryl
    http://www.secondlivesclub.com

  • http://remarkablewrinklies.com/ Patti Winker

    GREAT topic, Jane. I know many “gurus” personally and, yes, some of them do try to get me to focus a bit more on one niche in my blog. But, others see my blog more like I do… a deposit for my ramblings about living life after 50 and beyond.

    The best advice I’ve gotten from the gurus I know (and love!) is to write from my heart in my blog and the niche will follow. Now that I’ve been writing for a while, I discovered a couple niches within my blog and promote products to fit those niches, and I do just fine.

    But, mostly, I enjoy writing! Am I a success? When I write a blog post that I like, I’m happy. When people find me and read my writing, I’m happy. When people like me enough to ask me to write for them, I’m happy. So, yes, I’d say I’m successful.

    I blog, therefore I am, too! Thanks Jane!

Previous post:

Next post: