Dressing for Midlife: Who Gets To Say What’s Age Appropriate?

Crossposted by Jane of  ByJane

What’s your opinion on fashion for the forty and over set? I’ve been reading More magazine and frankly, it’s pissing me off. Last month Lesley Jane Seymour devoted her Editor’s Column to dressing one’s age. She described standing behind a woman at a hotel in Hollywood and trying to figure out how old she was by the visual cues: long blonde hair meant 40, mini skirt pushed it to 35, and bright colors signaled “under 30, for sure.” Then the woman turned around and revealed

“(cue screech music from Psycho) a woman of a certain age who was trying desperately . . . to avoid looking a certain age. . . .Being of a Certain Age myself, I felt terrifically sad that this woman had gazed out over the fashion landscape and seen no appealing style stops between Thirty-Five and…Dead. . . .deliberately dressing 20 years younger than your birth date is setting yourself up to commit a kind of sartorial shock and awe.”

It’s taken me a month to stop sputtering at the slings and arrows that Seymour was flinging at me and every other woman who doesn’t fit the New York fashion world’s version of what she calls “Age Appropriate Style.” What does that mean, anyway? Seymour asks us these questions: “If you have great legs, should you still show them off at 60? If your arms are trim and fit, can you go sleeveless at any age?” Hell, yes, I say. I certainly don’t want to scare Seymour (or anyone else who is standing behind me in line), but my hair is long and my skirts are not because that’s the way I want them. I have thought both issues through and I’m sure of my reasoning, and it has nothing to do with trying to look younger.

What bothers me so much about Seymour’s edicts is that More is the only mainstream publication that focuses consistently on midlife women. They do a good job of offering articles that encourage us to take chances, break out of the box, go for as full a life as you can possibly imagine. But this encouragement clearly doesn’t extend to our physical selves since the magazine offers a steady round of stick thin models wearing designer clothing. I don’t know about you, but this midlife woman hasn’t been stick thin since she was in her thirties, and she cannot afford, especially in this economy, $1500 dresses and $800 shoes.

So here’s my challenge. How are you dressing these days? For comfort? For fashion? For yourself or your significant other? Think about it; maybe you have some photos to share. I’ll publish all that I get on MidLifeBloggers.com. Let’s turn that into the fashion magazine for midlifers, the one no one else is publishing

Popularity: 13% [?]

  • http://www.arubagirl.blogspot.com Kate

    Dear Jane:

    I so connect with this post. I’m 54 and am constantly wondering if I’m dressing “age appropriate” and I absolutely can’t stand that term either. It makes me feel imprisoned.

    When I was 52 I was shopping for a cocktail dress to wear to a Christmas event and my eye caught this most gorgeous blood red knee length dress. It had an open criss cross back and exposed some chest. I tried it on and fell in love; perhaps with a memory of how I was at age 25 or 35; the dress was made for a woman 20-30 years younger. I ended up buying it and wearing it but only ONCE. I though at the time I looked great but it was like Cinderella at the stroke of midnight; by the time I got home that evening I knew the dress was a one time deal and I felt saddened. Had my time passed?

    I am trim and fit into the dress just fine. But skin doesn’t lie. My skin wasn’t 35 years old in that dress and there wasn’t a damn thing I could do about it. I haunted myself with questions like “what did people think?”, “was I over the top?” The dress sits in my closet; I see it every day and constantly wish we could figure out what to do about this thorny issue of what’s ok and what’ not ok.

    If you do have a photo spread of mid lifers wearing clothes that raise the question, I’ll send you mine.

    Keep writing!

  • http://www.girlsgardenofmenopause.com/ Ellen

    My wardrobe has taken multiple hits in recent years. I’m a work-at-home freelancer, so I don’t need a lot of client-go-to-meetin’ outfits. I’ve gained about 20 lbs in the last three years, so a lot of my clothes don’t fit anymore. And I’m contending with hot flashes so I’m constantly throwing clothes off…then putting them on…then throwing them off again. I am seriously contemplating remaining sleeveless through the winter–despite the fact that I live in Minnesota!

    Right now, I’m down to two skirts, one lightweight jacket, a couple of basic cotton sweaters, one pair of black moleskin jeans and one pair of regular jeans. My business has slowed way down so I’m uneasy about shopping for new clothes. But, even if I felt flush, it would be dispiriting to buy bigger sizes.

    So, unless I find a lamp with a genie who’d be willing to grant me my dearest wish–flying to London and putting me in the hands of the bitchy-but-effective Trinny & Susannah of the original BBC version of What Not To Wear–I think I’m resigned to spend the Recession of ’08-09 looking like a dowdy dog walker.

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Kate: I wondered what happened that night, what slight glance or comment, so changed the red dress for you. I get the skin thing (lord knows, looking at my arms and legs, I get it!), but why is that dress (or its genre) only to be worn by those who have perfect flesh? I’ve been quoting Wordsworth’s Intimations Ode my entire adult live. “What though the radiance…etc.etc.etc.” seems to fit every occasion.

    I hope I have enough responses to call you on that photo offer.

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Ellen: Ever since my aneurysm AND my weight gain AND menopause, I’ve felt a mess. I started buying my clothes at Target–which would work if I had them tailored. Of course, that would make the cost of them equal to what I could buy at Nordstrom. I’ve also thought about hitting up What Not To Wear and How Do I Look and the Project Runway guy for help. I’m sure I could spin an enticing story (see first sentence), but I don’t because–what if I didn’t like the clothing they chose for me. Plus, the public humiliation…oh woe.

  • http://suburbsanity.blogspot.com/ Debbie

    Well said! Now when did the fashions of 40 and up women become such a national crisis that we have to spend so much time being told how to dress? I am also upset when More does this. I love that magazine – most of the time. Perhaps some of their writers should not be based in NYC. There are middle aged women elsewhere who don’t cave to these artificial fashion (or life) constraints. I wear what I want, that I think looks good on me, and that makes me feel good about myself. I don’t dress for anyone else.

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Well said, back again to you! Definitely they need writers who aren’t NY-centric. Nina Garcia from Elle (and Project Runway) has a new advice book out and I’m wondering what rules she has got in store for us.

    So what do you wear? I’m curious…

  • http://suburbsanity.blogspot.com/ Debbie

    Mostly cheap stuff from Target, jeans from Old Navy, bright tacky colors, and whatever I feel like!

  • http://vintagemommy.com Vintage Mommy

    I think this is just another chapter in the campaign to erode women’s confidence through criticizing their appearance.

    As someone who has struggled with her weight all her life, I’ve always hesitated to wear certain clothing – if I could even find “certain clothing”. Ironically I’m in better shape now! For me body image issues came long before midlife, and I haven’t thought a lot about age-appropriate dressing.

    This is a really interesting topic!

  • http://nanadiaries.com KJ

    I wear things I like. That means, I wear jeans, bermuda shorts, skimpy tops, and t-shirts, etc. To work I wear suits and nice slacks and tops, as always. I pretty much wear what I always have, but with modifications, according to current styles and the changing shape of my body.

    What I can’t do now that I used to do (and am now paying for) is wear strappy sandals. My feet LOOK fine, but the inner workings are broken down from all the years of high heels. So now though I want to wear the latest very cute heels, I relegate myself to the Clark’s and Borne footwear for comfort. I have made adjustments to the styles I wear, but mostly that’s because my stomach isn’t flat anymore. I can’t wear midriffs unless I want people to think I’m pregnant (at my age!), and I can’t wear pants too tight across my hips and butt because, well there’s more in them thar hills than I want to show the world now. I can’t wear shorts or mini-skirts either, but that’s because my legs have become orange peels.

    I don’t want More Magazine or anybody else telling me what I should and shouldn’t wear because of my age. I’ll wear what I want when I want to. I even wear white (gasp!) after September!

    KJ
    http://nanadiaries.com

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Vintage Mommy: I hear your frustration, but I think it’s more complicated than a campaign to erode women’s confidence. After all, the purpose of these particular fashion do’s and don’ts is to increase our confidence by insuring that we don’t make fools of ourselves by dressing too young. But the problem is that the arbiters of the rules are operating from their particular biases. Thus, a New York editor like Seymour sees bright colors as the province of under thirties; in California, the all black wardrobe of the typical New Yorker would be a depressing fashion faux pas. It’s all relative and a helpful fashion guide would speak not only to our body type and age, but our location as well.

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    KJ: Would you care to model an outfit or two for us????

  • http://www.midlifeandbeyond.blogspot.com Midlife Mama

    **sigh** I have no sense of style. I SO need Stacy and Clinton on “What Not To Wear.” Oh, and losing 100 lbs. would help. LOL

  • http://nanadiaries.com KJ

    HA! Maybe when I lose 20 pounds, I’ll model for ya . . . Actually, I’m not the model type — too short and pear-shaped. I just want to be comfortable and stylish at the same time, and I don’t need somebody with a rule book telling me I passed or failed on what I pulled out of my closet for the day. And believe me, if I’ve worn anything inappropriate for ME, my daughters will be sure I don’t get away with it. Who needs More Mag when I’ve got four daughters?

    KJ
    http://nanadiaries.com

  • http://www.midlifeonwheels.com On Da Road

    Not much sense of style here either. I lost almost 40 pounds this year and dropped several sizes along the way.. so I am just sticking to my younger sisters hand-me-downs till I find a size landing place. My sisters a shopper fashion girl, I’m not .. so when I land I let her go pick out something for me that is ‘in’ so she isn’t embarrassed to be around me and comfy so I will actually wear it.

  • Diane

    If I lived in NYC or Dallas I would worry about whether my clothes are fancy schmancy, color coordinated, magazine cover ready designer quality. Or maybe not. Alas, I live in come as you are Austin TX and that is alright with me. Can’t think of any place I would go here that would require me to think my age let alone dress it! And yet I watch Project Runway every year and wait to hear the fashion critiques from Michael Kors and Nina Garcia with great antici—pa—-tion as Dr. Frankenfurter would say. My favorite show was the one where the contestants had to design costumes for some drag queens. No concerns about age or sex appropriate attire in that show! A lesson for us all. If it looks and feels good on you, I say wear it.

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Diane,
    I think there’s a nascent fashion groupie in those of us who watch PR. I live in a city that makes Austin look like Manhattan, but I’m still fascinated by fashion…even when I can’t or don’t want to wear it. I guess what I’m trying to figure out in these posts is–why! And why so many people think they should tell others how to dress…

Previous post:

Next post: