Our Bodies

What We See In The Mirror and How We Feel About It

Our Careers

The work that we do and that we wish we did

Our Minds

Our emotional, spiritual, and intellectual selves

Our Relationships

Mates, children, parents, siblings, friends

Our World

What we think about what’s happening outside our door

Home » All Our Voices

Bodysnarking nastiness

Submitted by byjane on Monday, 21 July 20088 Comments

By Ellen Besso of MidLife Maze

In the Vancouver Sun recently, there was an article on bodysnarking, a term I was unfamiliar with. I knew women were cruel to other women about bodies and body image, I just didn’t know it was this formallized, I guess I could say.

According to the article,

“bodysnarking involves mercilessly appraising ordinary people’s appearances on a worldwide playing field that includes social networking hubs, photo-sharing services and blogs…policing personal imperfections…”

You know, this approach isn’t really that surprising given the tortuous pulling apart of women on fashion makeover shows and the sometimes nasty critiques on American Idol. Basically those shows, and other written media have modelled and taught people (who one could argue, are impressionable), to do this. Glamour Magazine has had a website page, called3 perfectly normal women Don’tspotting since 2006, that encourages women to criticize their peers’ appearances. (the pic of 3 very normal looking women is from dontspotting)

A recent television ad for Cadbury Thins (100 calories per package) shows a woman, with a shake of her head and a negative expression, discouraging another woman from buying a dress she’s trying on, because she wants it for herself. There’s nothing wrong with the way the dress looks on the first woman, but she trusted that the opinion of the second woman was an honest and accurate one. Consequently she didn’t buy the dress, and the second woman got it!

Whatever happened to women supporting women?? I wrote to the Cadbury company and said I thought this ad was going against years of feminism. In their first reply to me they said they had marketed tested the ad before using it and it had been vetted by their testers. In their next reply, from another department, they said the ad had been discontinued!, much to my surprise, and pleasure. I’d sure like to hear some of the other negative criticisms they received about it. They also said they were sending me some Thins for my trouble!!

So where does this leave midlife women, most of whom (I hope), have philosphies that are kinder to their fellow woman? We’re just as aware of the fashion messages, and for the push for perfection in the area of beauty and appearance (like in many areas of our culture). I guess a lot of us try to strike a middleground, of grooming and dressing (half-way) decently in a way that pleases our own selves…and not trying to look like we’re 20 years old.

8 Comments »

  • susan m says:

    I think snarkiness represents “wanting to be part of the tribe”…. the same urge we had in junior high, when we did everything we could to fit in. It’s a way of saying, “I’m hip but not fringe. I know what’s cool and what’s not. My judgment is solid. I know not to wear those clothes, and just to prove it I’ll make fun of those who do.”

    It’s even a strange type of leadership behavior…. people trying to establish themselves as trendsetters and influence peddlers, the next Perez or Gawker or Go Fug Yourself. After all, it worked for them.

    Eventually most people realize that gossips/snarkers don’t make good friends. And that karma has a way of coming back around… especially when one’s butt starts to sag and the belly begins to pooch. Midlife — the best sensitivity training program anywhere!

    Ellen Besso reply on July 27th, 2008 7:55 pm:

    Hi Susan: Thanks for your post. This ‘wanting to be part of the tribe’ idea of yours makes a lot of sense. So mags like Glamour are cashing in on that huh?…the self-image issues, etc.
    It’s pretty scary when we identify ourselves only by outward appearance isn’t it?
    That’s so true about midlife being a sensitivity training program! I love it. Our ego kind of gets hit over & over again, by the physical stuff & the out-of-control feelings. (Eckhart Tolle would love it).

    Ellen Besso
    http://www.ellenbesso.com/midlifemaze

  • Margaret says:

    I’ve never heard the term “bodysnarking” either although I can’t wait to slip it into everyday conversation the first chance I get!

    Since such behavior has gone on since the dawn of gossip, I don’t see how it could go away anytime soon. Not that we shouldn’t smack those who are all too eager to support and exarcerbate THE underlying cause of anorexia and other body-image-related issues.

    Ellen Besso reply on July 25th, 2008 3:45 pm:

    Hi Margaret: Yes, use it, it will get people’s attention, won’t it! I’m so disappointed that mags like Glamour would propagate this idea with their ‘don’tspotting’.

    There’s a new ad out now (I usually watch w/o the sound), but it seems to be similar to the Cadbury Thins one – 2 women trying to outdo each other over the best appliances!!! if you can imagine!

    I sure hope high-schools deal with this skinny & perfect image stuff in courses. I’m sure some do.

    Warm regards
    Ellen Besso
    http://www.ellenbesso.com/midlifemaze

  • Denise says:

    In my most paranoid moments, I suspect men are behind this type of thing, fearing the power of women united.
    I fear for my daughters and nieces who are growing up in this culture and I try to promote kindness, to themselves and others.
    As for me, I ignore it as it applies to me. I do the best I can to take care of myself and rejoice in how much my husband loves me just the way I am.

    Ellen Besso reply on July 25th, 2008 3:41 pm:

    Hi Denise: I think men are behind it…in a way…Women pride themselves on being able to manage so many things better than men for example multi-tasking – (I was just writing bout this yesterday)- & therefore put themselves in a position of trying to attain perfection, one-up-man-ship, etc. etc. Does this make sense, or am I going too far???

    I too fear for the younger ones. (my daughter is 27, a little too old to buy all that…& of course a feminist!).

    Warm regards
    Ellen Besso
    http://www.ellenbesso.com/midlifemaze

  • As someone with lifelong body image and eating issues, I’m super-sensitive to this stuff. It’s amazing how quickly women will turn on each other in this department, and I’m not sure it gets better as we get older!

    Ellen Besso reply on July 25th, 2008 3:37 pm:

    Hi Ann: I hear you! I think things were bad enough in ‘the old days’ before the media explosion. Now we’re inundated constantly with the ways we should look (& act). Younger people may buy into this hook, line & sinker! I like to think we’re kinder to each other as we age…but I’m not sure either.

    Warm regards
    Ellen Besso
    http://www.ellenbesso.com/midlifemaze