Friendship at Midlife: Are the days of BFF over?

kanji-symbols-for-friendshipThe shifting sands of midlife friendship

by Cindy of Cindy LaFerle’s Home Office


“I have lost friends, some by death, others through the sheer inability to cross the street.” – Virginia Woolf

Middle age can be incredibly liberating. We might stop basing our choices on the needs or desires of other people. We stop saying “yes” to every request. We’re more discriminating when we decide how to spend our time — and with whom.

Looking back over the past several years, I realize that many of my social relationships were built on the shifting sands of proximity or shared experience.

When I was much younger, I had several “best friends” in the neighborhood where I grew up.  I recently reconnected with one from high school, and we were both thrilled to find we’re just as compatible today. But most of my girlhood friends have moved on or lost touch.

Former coworkers who once shared office space and long lunch hours also come to mind. I’ve enjoyed several years of corporate camaraderie, and a few people with whom I’ve worked are still an active part of my social life now. (Two former editors still celebrate their holidays and birthdays with my family.) But most of my professional friendships faded when I changed jobs.

I’m also thinking of my son’s grade-school years, when I volunteered to work at countless school events and became friendly with a great group of mothers. Occasionally we’d meet for dinner  — or several glasses of Chardonnay — without the husbands and kids. Or we’d host rowdy playground picnics with our little ones. And there were the moms in my son’s Cub Scout troop — the intrepid gals who braved rainy camping trips in the woods and bonded over S’mores around the campfire. More often than not, we didn’t have much else in common aside from our kids. But we made some happy memories together.

From my middle-aged perspective, I know that transitions in friendship tend to happen naturally, over time — especially in a highly mobile culture like ours. We move to new cities; we get busy with our families; we change and grow. We stop exchanging holiday cards and remembering birthdays. And if we’re lucky, hurt feelings aren’t a factor.  Sometimes, though, guilt and hurt feelings are unavoidable.

Recently, for example, I found myself dragging my heels on my way to a lunch date with an old acquaintance who believes we’re closer than we really are. She’s a very nice person, but our relationship has barely skimmed the surface of things. And while it worked on that level at one time, in a different place, it doesn’t work here and now. I feel insincere spending time with this friend when my heart’s not in it.

Over the years, I’ve learned it’s never healthy to cling to any alliance that’s emotionally draining or one-sided or otherwise uncomfortable. As Emerson said, friendship should offer “mutual aid and comfort” through life’s passages. I think it should be fun, too.

  • http://www.womenscoachingcenter.com Marcia

    It’s so true that friendships can change so dramatically at this time in life. There can be a period of real loneliness until we realign ourselves with positive, energizing forces. I’ve learned that we have to be ourselves to get others to gravitate to that authentic self and until we are ready, it seems as if we just keep attracting more of what we always do. I often say that at midlife we need a couple of good friends who let us kick our shoes off and be ourselves—whatever that self is.

  • http://www.missykrissy2005.blogspot.com MissKris

    I wrote recently in a blog entry about “If I’d only known then what I know now” list how I would’ve held on to some friendships thru life more closely and let others go a long time ago. Maybe it’s because my life is so crammed full right now but I have next-to-no time for friendships any more, outside of those here on the computer. And I think that’s because whoever I know/need on here is here when I have the time to devote to them. Face-to-face friendship takes sooooooooooo much time and effort that I don’t have right now…I do day care for two toddler grandsons 55 hours per week. Thankfully my best friend of 42 years understands and is basically in the same predicament, caring for her terminally ill m-i-l who’s living with her and her husband right now so our friendship at this stage consists of dashed-off emails to each other. I’m not a very social creature anyway so I don’t require much outside of a core group of friends I’ve had for many years. Superficial friendships have come and gone thru the years, tho there have been a few of those I wish I could’ve held on to if circumstances had been different. Right now what I wish I had more of in life is sleep and TIME, ha!

  • http://fabgrandma.blogspot.com/ Karen

    I have always felt that if I am not getting at least 30% of what I give in a friendship it is time to move on. We all change and grow in different ways. Sometimes it is best to just acknowledge that the relationship was good when it was good, but to move on when it no longer serves any good purpose. There are way too many people in the world to spend precious time with people who are not “there”.

  • http://www.laferle.com Cindy La Ferle

    Hi everyone,
    Sorry to have been out of the picture all week … after the Memorial Day holiday, I’ve been out of town helping my twenty-something son move into his first home in Chicago.

    Laura, you made a comment about friends being more like “family,” and that hit home with me. As time goes by, my husband and I find that our best friends are the ones with whom we can share our deepest cares and concerns — and they feel more like family than our real siblings much of the time. Ben Jonson once said, “Friends are a family — a family one chooses.” Ain’t that the truth?? Our best friends do tend to be those with whom we have a shared history.

    As I wrote in the original post, I do think friendship morphs and changes as we age. Proximity has a lot to do with it, but then again, the heart has its own reasons. I also believe we learn something from every friendship.

  • http://www.sasstown.com the Mayor

    Cindy- I agree with your perspective on moving through phases of life and the different people that become comrades. But I have to agree with Duchess and the loyalty issue with those who have stuck with you whether you wanted them to or not.

    Does it not almost get back to the wanting to be friends with the popular”with it” girl when your true friend might be the one who is always a mess with sesame seeds in her teeth, but shows up when you run out of gas?

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Don’t know what happened to Cindy, so I’ll stick my two cents in here.

    OnDaRoad: It seems like my “best” friends, the ones who stay true, are those who I’ve known since I was young. More recently I’ve been disappointed in the way friends I thought were “best” are now just barely acquaintences.

    Laura: That thing of mirroring still goes on for me with my closest friends, and it’s what I find nourishes me. I can be in a funk, but I know if I talk to this friend or that, even when she’s in the same funk, I leave the conversation feeling heard.

    Duchess: The stickiness of true friends…now that’s a post in the making.

    Kat: My best friends, the ones that have stuck, are mostly those I have a LOONNNGGG history with. Janice, who is my partner in MLB, and I met in 9th grade. We’ve drifted apart over the years when our lives were going different directions, but it only took a minute or two to get right back into the conversation we started way back when. The same is true of Liz and Laurie and George and Marilyn and Dorothy. That connection is what I look for in a friend–and what I’ve not really found lately.

    Chris: I too have moved so many times. This is the first time, however, that I haven’t really connected in that way with anyone. Don’t know why? Maybe it’s me?

  • http://www.btc-boutique.com/blog Chris

    I’ve moved so many times and each time it’s been a different dynamic for making friends. Early on it was without kids, so friends evolved from work relationships. Subsequent moves had babies in tow so community playgroups were a godsend for friendship building. Later, school aged alliances formed with the parents of my kids’ friends. Now as my kids get older, facing another move, I think common interests will be the key to new connections. I’ve found openness to new people brings so many great surprises. Also, Facebook is a gift to maintaining old friendships. Shifting sands? Definitely. But it’s infinitely interesting meeting new people.

  • http://happyhourandjack.blogspot.com Kat

    Most of the friends I have now I know from my kids when they were in school. To tell you the truth, I’m not even sure how you would make friends in middle age. I had a friend move away for a few years and she could not wait to move back so she could have her friends back…and boy we were happy to have her back. I have been thinking of moving to San Diego where I have 2 brothers but really don’t know anyone. I imagine if I were to make new friends it would be though old friends, but if you don’t have any old friends in your area, then what? Book clubs? Meet up groups? My friend said it was really hard to make friends in her new neighborhood, which was so odd as she is a a very friendly lady.

    But, I totally get the changing times. Some of my friends are themselves changing with our kids now much older, young 20s for the most part, and interests have changed. Who knew being in your 50s would bring such changes?!

  • http://www.duchessomnium.com Duchess

    Sometimes, it seems to me, life long friends end up being the people who refuse to be dropped or get lost. It isn’t perhaps that you loved them best, just that they were best at sticking.

  • http://www.rebelliousthoughtsofawoman.com Laura

    I have found that the friendships I have now are ones that I might not have had when I was younger, and expecting one friend to be, in a sense, a mirror to me or with whom I could spend hours and hours. Now, most of my friends are those who I have known for a few years, and history is one of the links that we have to each other. Perhaps they are more like family, since when we get together we mull over the past and catch each other up to where we are in life. The discussions are less philosophical, meaning of life stuff, and more comfort on a personal level. Or, I have found the friends to be what I need from friendships. At a certain point it’s also hard to find new friends, so I really cherish the one’s I have.

  • http://www.midlifeonwheels.com On Da Road

    I tend try and hold on longer than I should to friendships. People, our interests and circumstances change throughout our lives. I value very much the very few that I have been able to move through those transitions with.

  • http://midlifebloggers.com byjane

    Those shifting sands confuse me because I’ve had/have such close, long-term friendships that when someone I think is a good friend disappears, I don’t know what to make of it.

  • http://www.thefiftyfactor.com Joanna Jenkins

    Oh Cindy, I hear you loud and clear! I miss a few of my “long lost friends” but mostly I cherish the friendships I have now. They are so much more meaningful and deeper relationships that come with age, and experience, and CHOICE. The older I get the more I find my few close friendships today to be more honest and mutual. I know without a doubt my “middle aged” friendships will be friends through the long haul. It’s a good feeling. Terrific post!

Previous post:

Next post: